Red Velvet’s Irene Faces Backlash Over Latest Encore Performance

Red Velvet’s Irene is facing backlash over her recent encore performance following her solo music show win with “Biggest Fan.”

The controversy began when clips of Irene’s live vocals from the encore started circulating online. Many netizens criticized her singing, calling parts of the performance “off-pitch” and questioning her overall vocal delivery. Some viewers described the performance as “awkward” and “lacking,” noting a clear difference between the live vocals and the studio recording.

“The song is apparently just one note, and she can’t even hit that.”

“She’s so happy to sound a mess?? This what you call nugu privilege.”

The backlash quickly grew, with harsh comments flooding online communities. Some pointed out that Irene’s vocal skills haven’t improved much despite her years in the industry. Others suggested she wasn’t ready for a solo debut and that her win was surprising given her performance level.

Fans quickly reacted to defend Irene. They argued the original track relies heavily on layered vocals, which can make live versions sound different. Many also said Irene seemed relaxed and playful on stage, which might have affected how her singing came across.

Online reactions included:

• “I haven’t listened to the song so I can’t say much, but I feel like she was like this even during Red Velvet promotions… It’s honestly surprising her skills haven’t improved much for her years in the industry.”

• “She wasn’t really at a level to go solo in the first place, so it’s honestly more surprising she got No.1 with those skills at her experience level.”

• “It’s because she’s from SM Entertainment that she’s getting defended so fiercely like this.”

• “She originally had an image of being decent at vocals, but it feels like she lost her pitch here.”

The debate has spread across multiple platforms, dividing opinions between those scrutinizing her live singing and those emphasizing the tough expectations idols face during encore stages. Despite the criticism, Irene’s solo win remains a major milestone in her career beyond Red Velvet.

Listen to Irene’s full encore performance here: